Options
Dr. Astudillo-Defru, Nicola
Nombre de publicación
Dr. Astudillo-Defru, Nicola
Nombre completo
Astudillo Defru, Nicola
Facultad
Email
nastudillo@ucsc.cl
ORCID
46 results
Research Outputs
Now showing 1 - 10 of 46
- PublicationAtmospheric characterization and tighter constraints on the orbital misalignment of WASP-94 A b with HARPS(Oxford Academic, 2024)
; ;Ahrer, E. ;Seidel, J. ;Doyle, L. ;Gandhi, S. ;Prinoth, B. ;Cegla, H. ;McDonald, C. ;Ayache, E. ;Nealon, R. ;Veras, Dimitri ;Wheatley, P.Ehrenreich, D.We present high spectral resolution observations of the hot Jupiter WASP-94 A b using the HARPS instrument on ESO’s 3.6-m telescope in La Silla, Chile. We probed for Na absorption in its atmosphere as well as constrained the previously reported misaligned retrograde orbit using the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect. Additionally, we undertook a combined atmospheric retrieval analysis with previously published low-resolution data. We confirm the retrograde orbit as well as constrain the orbital misalignment with our measurement of a projected spin-orbit obliquity of λ = 123.0 ± 3.0°. We find a tentative detection of Na absorption in the atmosphere of WASP-94 A b, independent of the treatment of the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect in our analysis (3.6σ and 4.4σ). We combine our HARPS high-resolution data with low-resolution data from the literature and find that while the posterior distribution of the Na abundance results in a tighter constraint than using a single data set, the detection significance does not improve (3.2σ), which we attribute to degeneracies between the low- and high-resolution data. - PublicationTOI-663: A newly discovered multi-planet system with three transiting mini-Neptunes orbiting an early M star(EDP Sciences, 2024)
; ;Cointepas, M. ;Bouchy, F. ;Almenara, J. ;Bonfils, X. ;Knierim, H. ;Stalport, M. ;Mignon, L. ;Grieves, N. ;Bean, J. ;Brady, M. ;Burt, J. ;Canto-Martins, B. ;Collins, K. ;Collins, K. ;Delfosse, X. ;de Medeiros, J. ;Demory, B. ;Dorn, C. ;Forveille, T. ;Fukui, A. ;Gan, T. ;Gómez-Maqueo-Chew, Y. ;Halverson, S. ;Helled, R. ;Helm, I. ;Hirano, T. ;Horne, K. ;Howell, S. ;Isogai, K. ;Kasper, D. ;Kawauchi, K. ;Livingston, J. ;Massey, B. ;Matson, R. ;Murgas, F. ;Narita, N. ;Palle, E. ;Relles, H. ;Sabin, L. ;Schanche, N. ;Schwarz, R. ;Seifahrt, A. ;Shporer, A. ;Stefansson, G. ;Sturmer, J. ;Tamura, M. ;Tan, T. ;Twicken, J. ;Watanabe, N. ;Wells, R. ;Wilkin, F. ;Ricker, G. ;Seager, S. ;Winn, J.Jenkins, J.We present the detection of three exoplanets orbiting the early M dwarf TOI-663 (TIC 54962195; V = 13.7 mag, J = 10.4 mag, R★ = 0.512 ± 0.015 R⊙, M★ = 0.514 ± 0.012 M⊙, d = 64 pc). TOI-663 b, c, and d, with respective radii of 2.27 ± 0.10 R⊕, 2.26 ± 0.10 R⊕, and 1.92 ± 0.13 R⊕ and masses of 4.45 ± 0.65 M⊕, 3.65 ± 0.97 M⊕, and <5.2 M⊕ at 99%, are located just above the radius valley that separates rocky and volatile-rich exoplanets. The planet candidates are identified in two TESS sectors and are validated with ground-based photometric follow-up, precise radial-velocity measurements, and high-resolution imaging. We used the software package juliet to jointly model the photometric and radial-velocity datasets, with Gaussian processes applied to correct for systematics. The three planets discovered in the TOI-663 system are low-mass mini-Neptunes with radii significantly larger than those of rocky analogs, implying that volatiles, such as water, must predominate. In addition to this internal structure analysis, we also performed a dynamical analysis that confirmed the stability of the system. The three exoplanets in the TOI-663 system, similarly to other sub-Neptunes orbiting M dwarfs, have been found to have lower densities than planets of similar sizes orbiting stars of different spectral types. - PublicationTOI-4860 b, a short-period giant planet transiting an M3.5 dwarf(EDP Sciences, 2024)
; ;Almenara, J. ;Bonfils, X. ;Bryant, E. ;Jordán, A. ;Hébrard, G. ;Martioli, E. ;Correia, A. ;Cadieux, C. ;Arnold, L. ;Artigau, É. ;Bakos, G. ;Barros, S. ;Bayliss, D. ;Bouchy, F. ;Boué, G. ;Brahm, R. ;Carmona, A. ;Charbonneau, D. ;Ciardi, D. ;Cloutier, R. ;Cointepas, M. ;Cook, N. ;Cowan, N. ;Delfosse, X. ;Dias do Nascimento, J. ;Donati, J. ;Doyon, R. ;Forveille, T. ;Fouqué, P. ;Gaidos, E. ;Gilbert, E. ;da Silva, J. ;Hartman, J. ;Hesse, K. ;Hobson, M. ;Jenkins, J. ;Kiefer, F. ;Kostov, V. ;Laskar, J. ;Lendl, M. ;L’Heureux, A. ;Martins, J. ;Menou, K. ;Moutou, C. ;Murgas, F. ;Polanski, A. S. ;Rapetti, D. ;Sedaghati, E.Shang, H.We report the discovery and characterisation of a giant transiting planet orbiting a nearby M3.5V dwarf (d = 80.4pc, G = 15.1 mag, K=11.2mag, R* = 0.358 ± 0.015 R⊙, M* = 0.340 ± 0.009 M⊙). Using the photometric time series from TESS sectors 10, 36, 46, and 63 and near-infrared spectrophotometry from ExTrA, we measured a planetary radius of 0.77 ± 0.03 RJ and an orbital period of 1.52 days. With high-resolution spectroscopy taken by the CFHT/SPIRou and ESO/ESPRESSO spectrographs, we refined the host star parameters ([Fe/H] = 0.27 ± 0.12) and measured the mass of the planet (0.273 ± 0.006 MJ). Based on these measurements, TOI-4860 b joins the small set of massive planets (>80 ME) found around mid to late M dwarfs (<0.4 R⊙), providing both an interesting challenge to planet formation theory and a favourable target for further atmospheric studies with transmission spectroscopy. We identified an additional signal in the radial velocity data that we attribute to an eccentric planet candidate (e = 0.66 ± 0.09) with an orbital period of 427 ± 7 days and a minimum mass of 1.66 ± 0.26 MJ, but additional data would be needed to confirm this. - PublicationValidation of a Third Planet in the LHS 1678 System(IOP Publishing, 2024)
; ;Silverstein, Michele ;Barclay, Thomas ;Schlieder, Joshua ;Collins, Karen ;Schwarz, Richard ;Hord, Benjamin ;Rowe, Jason ;Kruse, Ethan ;Bonfils, Xavier ;Caldwell, Douglas ;Charbonneau, David ;Cloutier, Ryan ;Collins, Kevin ;Daylan, Tansu ;Fong, William ;Jenkins, Jon ;Kunimoto, Michelle ;McDermott, Scott ;Murgas, Felipe ;Palle, Enric ;Ricker, George ;Seager, Sara ;Shporer, Avi ;Tey, Evan ;Vanderspek, RolandWinn, JoshuaThe nearby LHS 1678 (TOI-696) system contains two confirmed planets and a wide-orbit, likely brown-dwarf companion, which orbit an M2 dwarf with a unique evolutionary history. The host star occupies a narrow “gap” in the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram lower main sequence, associated with the M dwarf fully convective boundary and long-term luminosity fluctuations. This system is one of only about a dozen M dwarf multiplanet systems to date that hosts an ultra-short-period planet (USP). Here we validate and characterize a third planet in the LHS 1678 system using TESS Cycle 1 and 3 data and a new ensemble of ground-based light curves. LHS 1678 d is a 0.98 ± 0.07 R⊕ planet in a 4.97 day orbit, with an insolation flux of -+ 9.1 0.8 SÅ 0.9. These properties place it near 4:3 mean motion resonance with LHS 1678 c and in company with LHS 1678 c in the Venus zone. LHS 1678 c and d are also twins in size and predicted mass, making them a powerful duo for comparative exoplanet studies. LHS 1678 d joins its siblings as another compelling candidate for atmospheric measurements with the JWST and mass measurements using high-precision radial velocity techniques. Additionally, USP LHS 1678 b breaks the “peas-ina-pod” trend in this system although additional planets could fill in the “pod” beyond its orbit. LHS 1678ʼs unique combination of system properties and their relative rarity among the ubiquity of compact multiplanet systems around M dwarfs makes the system a valuable benchmark for testing theories of planet formation and evolution. - PublicationThe SOPHIE search for northern extrasolar planets. XIX. A system including a cold sub-Neptune potentially transiting a V = 6.5 star HD 88986(EDP Sciences, 2024)
; ;Heidari, N. ;Boisse, I. ;Hara, N. ;Wilson, T. ;Kiefer, F. ;Hébrard, G. ;Philipot, F. ;Hoyer, S. ;Stassun, K. ;Henry, G. ;Santos, N. ;Acuña, L. ;Almasian, D. ;Arnold, L. ;Attia, O. ;Bonfils, X. ;Bouchy, F. ;Bourrier, V. ;Collet, B. ;Cortés-Zuleta, P. ;Carmona, A. ;Delfosse, X. ;Dalal, S. ;Deleuil, M. ;Demangeon, O. ;Díaz, R. ;Dumusque, X. ;Ehrenreich, D. ;Forveille, T. ;Hobson, M. ;Jenkins, J. ;Jenkins, J. ;Lagrange, A. ;Latham, D. ;Larue, P. ;Liu, J. ;Moutou, C. ;Mignon, L. ;Osborn, H. ;Pepe, F. ;Rapetti, D. ;Rodrigues, J. ;Santerne, A. ;Segransan, D. ;Shporer, A. ;Sulis, S. ;Torres, G. ;Udry, S. ;Vakili, F. ;Vanderburg, A. ;Venot, O. ;Vivien, H.Vines, J.Transiting planets with orbital periods longer than 40 d are extremely rare among the 5000+ planets discovered so far. The lack of discoveries of this population poses a challenge to research into planetary demographics, formation, and evolution. Here, we present the detection and characterization of HD 88986 b, a potentially transiting sub-Neptune, possessing the longest orbital period among known transiting small planets (<4 R⊕) with a precise mass measurement (σM/M > 25%). Additionally, we identified the presence of a massive companion in a wider orbit around HD 88986. To validate this discovery, we used a combination of more than 25 yr of extensive radial velocity (RV) measurements (441 SOPHIE data points, 31 ELODIE data points, and 34 HIRES data points), Gaia DR3 data, 21 yr of photometric observations with the automatic photoelectric telescope (APT), two sectors of TESS data, and a 7-day observation of CHEOPS. Our analysis reveals that HD 88986 b, based on two potential single transits on sector 21 and sector 48 which are both consistent with the predicted transit time from the RV model, is potentially transiting. The joint analysis of RV and photometric data show that HD 88986 b has a radius of 2.49 ± 0.18 R⊕, a mass of 17.2−3.8+4.0 M⊕, and it orbits every 146.05−0.40+0.43 d around a subgiant HD 88986 which is one of the closest and brightest exoplanet host stars (G2Vtype, R = 1.543 ± 0.065 R⊙, V = 6.47 ± 0.01 mag, distance = 33.37 ± 0.04 pc). The nature of the outer, massive companion is still to be confirmed; a joint analysis of RVs, HIPPARCOS, and Gaia astrometric data shows that with a 3σ confidence interval, its semi-major axis is between 16.7 and 38.8 au and its mass is between 68 and 284 MJup. HD 88986 b’s wide orbit suggests the planet did not undergo significant mass loss due to extreme-ultraviolet radiation from its host star. Therefore, it probably maintained its primordial composition, allowing us to probe its formation scenario. Furthermore, the cold nature of HD 88986 b (460 ± 8 K), thanks to its long orbital period, will open up exciting opportunities for future studies of cold atmosphere composition characterization. Moreover, the existence of a massive companion alongside HD 88986 b makes this system an interesting case study for understanding planetary formation and evolution. - PublicationHot Exoplanet Atmospheres Resolved with Transit Spectroscopy (HEARTS) VIII. Nondetection of sodium in the atmosphere of the aligned planet KELT-10b(Astronomy & Astrophysics, 2023)
;Steiner,M. ;Attia, O. ;Ehrenreich, D. ;Lendl, M. ;Bourrier, V. ;Lovis, C. ;Seidel, J. ;Sousa, S. ;Mounzer, D.; ;Bonfils, X. ;Bonvin, V. ;Dethier, W. ;Heng, K. ;Lavie, B. ;Melo, C. ;Ottoni, G. ;Pepe, F. ;Ségransan, D.Wyttenbach, A.Context. The HEARTS survey aims to probe the upper layers of the atmosphere by detecting resolved sodium doublet lines, a tracer of the temperature gradient, and atmospheric winds. KELT-10b, one of the targets of HEARTS, is a hot-inflated Jupiter with 1.4 RJup and 0.7 MJup. Recently, there was a report of sodium absorption in the atmosphere of KELT-10b (0.66% ± 0.09% (D2) and 0.43% ± 0.09% (D1); VLT/UVES data from single transit). Aims. We searched for potential atmospheric species in KELT-10b, focusing on sodium doublet lines (Na I; 589 nm) and the Balmer alpha line (H α; 656 nm) in the transmission spectrum. Furthermore, we measured the planet-orbital alignment with the spin of its host star. Methods. We used the Rossiter–McLaughlin Revolutions technique to analyze the local stellar lines occulted by the planet during its transit. We used the standard transmission spectroscopy method to probe the planetary atmosphere, including the correction for telluric lines and the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect on the spectra. We analyzed two new light curves jointly with the public photometry observations. Results. We do not detect signals in the Na I and H α lines within the uncertainty of our measurements. We derive the 3σ upper limit of excess absorption due to the planetary atmosphere corresponding to equivalent height Rp to 1.8Rp (Na I) and 1.9Rp (H α). The analysis of the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect yields the sky-projected spin-orbit angle of the system λ = −5.2 ± 3.4◦ and the stellar projected equatorial velocity veq sin i⋆ = 2.58 ± 0.12 km s−1. Photometry results are compatible within 1σ with previous studies. Conclusions. We found no evidence of Na I and H α, within the precision of our data, in the atmosphere of KELT-10b. Our detection limits allow us to rule out the presence of neutral sodium or excited hydrogen in an escaping extended atmosphere around KELT-10b. We cannot confirm the previous detection of Na I at lower altitudes with VLT/UVES. We note, however, that the Rossiter–McLaughlin effect impacts the transmission spectrum on a smaller scale than the previous detection with UVES. Analysis of the planet-occulted stellar lines shows the sky-projected alignment of the system, which is likely truly aligned due to tidal interactions of the planet with its cool (Teff < 6250 K) host star. - PublicationAn unusually low-density super-Earth transiting the bright early-type M-dwarf GJ 1018 (TOI-244)(EDP Sciences, 2023)
;Demangeon,O. ;Lillo-Box, J. ;Lovis, C. ;Lavie, B. ;Adibekyan, V. ;Acuña, L. ;Deleuil, M. ;Aguichine, A. ;Zapatero-Osorio, M. ;Tabernero, H. ;Davoult, J. ;Alibert, Y. ;Santos, N. ;Sousa, S. ;Antoniadis-Karnavas, A. ;Borsa, F. ;Winn, J. ;Allende-Prieto, C. ;Figueira, M ;Jenkins, J. ;Sozzetti, A. ;Damasso, M. ;Silva, A.; ;Barros, C. ;Bonfils, X. ;Cristiani, S. ;Di Marcantonio, P. ;González-Hernández, J. ;Lo Curto, G. ;Martins, C. ;Nunes, N. ;Palle, E. ;Pepe, F. ;Seager, S.Suárez-Mascareño, A.Context. Small planets located at the lower mode of the bimodal radius distribution are generally assumed to be composed of iron and silicates in a proportion similar to that of the Earth. However, recent discoveries are revealing a new group of low-density planets that are inconsistent with that description. Aims. We intend to confirm and characterize the TESS planet candidate TOI-244.01, which orbits the bright (K = 7.97 mag), nearby (d = 22 pc), and early-type (M2.5 V) M-dwarf star GJ 1018 with an orbital period of 7.4 days. Methods. We used Markov chain Monte Carlo methods to model 57 precise radial velocity measurements acquired by the ESPRESSO spectrograph together with TESS photometry and complementary HARPS data. Our model includes a planetary component and Gaussian processes aimed at modeling the correlated stellar and instrumental noise. Results. We find TOI-244 b to be a super-Earth with a radius of Rp = 1.52 ± 0.12 R⊕ and a mass of Mp = 2.68 ± 0.30 M⊕. These values correspond to a density of ρ = 4.2 ± 1.1 g cm−3, which is below what would be expected for an Earth-like composition. We find that atmospheric loss processes may have been efficient to remove a potential primordial hydrogen envelope, but high mean molecular weight volatiles such as water could have been retained. Our internal structure modeling suggests that TOI-244 b has a 479+128 −96 km thick hydrosphere over a 1.17 ± 0.09 R⊕ solid structure composed of a Fe-rich core and a silicate-dominated mantle compatible with that of the Earth. On a population level, we find two tentative trends in the density-metallicity and density-insolation parameter space for the low-density super-Earths, which may hint at their composition. Conclusions. With a 8% precision in radius and 12% precision in mass, TOI-244 b is among the most precisely characterized super-Earths, which, together with the likely presence of an extended hydrosphere, makes it a key target for atmospheric observations - PublicationCharacterization of a Set of Small Planets with TESS and CHEOPS and an Analysis of Photometric Performance(Astronomical Journal, 2023)
;Dominic, Oddo ;Diana,Dragomir ;Brandeker, Alexis ;Osborn, Hugh P ;Collins, Karen ;Stassun, Keivan G.; ;Bieryla, Allyson ;Howell- B., Steve ;Ciardi, David ;Quinn, Samuel ;Almenara, Jose ;Briceño, César ;Collins, Kevin ;Colón, Knicole ;Conti, Dennis ;Crouzet, Nicolas ;Furlan, Elise ;Gan, Tianjun ;Gnilka, Cristal L. ;Goeke-Es, Robert ;González, Erica ;Mallory, Harris ;Jenkins, Jon ;Jensen, Eric ;Latham, David ;Ley, Nicolás ;Lund, Michael ;Mann, Andrew ;Bob, Massey ;Murgas, Felipe ;Ricker, George ;Relles, Howard ;Rowden, Pamela ;Schwarz, Richard ;Schlieder, Josué ;Shporer, Avi ;Seager, Sara ;Srdoc, Gregor ;Torres, Guillermo ;Twicken, Joseph ;Vanderspek, Roland ;Winn, JosuéZiegler, CarlThe radius valley carries implications for how the atmospheres of small planets form and evolve, but this feature is visible only with highly precise characterizations of many small planets. We present the characterization of nine planets and one planet candidate with both NASA TESS and ESA CHEOPS observations, which adds to the overall population of planets bordering the radius valley. While five of our planets—TOI 118 b, TOI 262 b, TOI 455 b, TOI 560 b, and TOI 562 b—have already been published, we vet and validate transit signals as planetary using follow-up observations for four new TESS planets, including TOI 198 b, TOI 244 b, TOI 444 b, and TOI 470 b. While a three times increase in primary mirror size should mean that one CHEOPS transit yields an equivalent model uncertainty in transit depth as about nine TESS transits in the case that the star is equally as bright in both bands, we find that our CHEOPS transits typically yield uncertainties equivalent to between two and 12 TESS transits, averaging 5.9 equivalent transits. Therefore, we find that while our fits to CHEOPS transits provide overall lower uncertainties on transit depth and better precision relative to fits to TESS transits, our uncertainties for these fits do not always match expected predictions given photon-limited noise. We find no correlations between number of equivalent transits and any physical parameters, indicating that this behavior is not strictly systematic, but rathe might be due to other factors such as in-transit gaps during CHEOPS visits or nonhomogeneous detrending of CHEOPS light curves. - PublicationCharacterisation of stellar activity of M dwarfs I. Long-timescale variability in a large sample and detection of new cycles(EDP Sciences, 2023)
;Mignon, L. ;Meunier, N. ;Delfosse, X. ;Bonfils, X. ;Santos, N. ;Forveille, T. ;Gaisné, G.; ;Lovis, C.Udry, S.Context. M dwarfs are active stars that exhibit variability in chromospheric emission and photometry at short and long timescales, including long cycles that are related to dynamo processes. This activity also impacts the search for exoplanets because it affects the radial velocities. Aims. We analysed a large sample of 177 M dwarfs observed with HARPS during the period 2003–2020 in order to characterise the long-term variability of these stars. We compared the variability obtained in three chromospheric activity indices (Ca II H & K, the Na D doublet, and Hα) and with ASAS photometry. Methods. We focused on the detailed analysis of the chromospheric emission based on linear, quadratic, and sinusoidal models. We used various tools to estimate the significance of the variability and to quantify the improvement brought by the models. In addition, we analysed complementary photometric time series for the most variable stars to be able to provide a broader view of the long-term variability in M dwarfs. Results. We find that most stars are significantly variable, even the quietest stars. Most stars in our sample (75%) exhibit a long-term variability, which manifests itself mostly through linear or quadratic variability, although the true behaviour may be more complex. We found significant variability with estimated timescales for 24 stars, and estimated the lower limit for a possible cycle period for an additional 9 stars that were not previously published. We found evidence of complex variability because more than one long-term timescale may be present for at least 12 stars, together with significant differences between the behaviour of the three activity indices. This complexity may also be the source of the discrepancies observed between previous publications. Conclusions. We conclude that long-term variability is present for all spectral types and activity level in M dwarfs, without a significant trend with spectral type or mean activity level. - PublicationCompany for the Ultra-high Density, Ultra-short Period Sub-Earth GJ 367 b: Discovery of Two Additional Low-mass Planets at 11.5 and 34 Days(The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 2023)
;Goffo, Elisa ;Gandolfi, Davide ;Jo Ann, Egger ;Mustill, Alejandro ;Albrecht, H. ;Teruyuki, Hirano ;Kochukhov, Oleg; ;Barragán, Oscar ;Serrano, Luisa ;Hatzes, Artie ;Alibert ;Guenther, Eike ;Fei, Dai ;Kristine W. F. Lam ;Szilárd Csizmadia ;Alexis M. S. Smith ;Fossati, Luca ;Luque, Rafael ;Rodler, Florian ;Winther, Mark ;Rørsted, Jakob ;Alarcon, Javier ;Bonfils, Xavier ;Cochran,William ;Deeg, Hans J. ;Jenkins, Jon M. ;Korth, Judith ;Livingston, John ;Meech, Annabella ;Murgas, Felipe ;Orell-Miquel, Jaume ;Osborne, Hannah ;Enric, Palle ;Persson, Carina M. ;Seth,Redfield ;Ricker, George ;Seager, Sara ;Vanderspek, RolandVan Eylen, VincentGJ 367 is a bright (V ≈ 10.2) M1 V star that has been recently found to host a transiting ultra-short period sub-Earth on a 7.7 hr orbit. With the aim of improving the planetary mass and radius and unveiling the inner architecture of the system, we performed an intensive radial velocity follow-up campaign with the HARPS spectrograph—collecting 371 high-precision measurements over a baseline of nearly 3 yr—and combined our Doppler measurements with new TESS observations from sectors 35 and 36. We found that GJ 367 b has a mass of Mb = 0.633 ± 0.050 M⊕ and a radius of Rb = 0.699 ± 0.024 R⊕, corresponding to precisions of 8% and 3.4%, respectively. This implies a planetary bulk density of ρb = 10.2 ± 1.3 g cm−3 , i.e., 85% higher than Earth’s density. We revealed the presence of two additional non-transiting low-mass companions with orbital periods of∼11.5 and 34 days and minimum masses of M isinc c = 4.13 ± 0.36 M⊕ and M isind d = 6.03 ± 0.49 M⊕respectively, which lie close to the 3:1 mean motion commensurability. GJ 367 b joins the small class of high-density planets, namely the class of super-Mercuries, being the densest ultra-short period small planet known to date. Thanks to our precise mass and radius estimates, we explored the potential internal composition and structure of GJ 367 b, and found that it is expected to have an iron core with a mass fraction of -+ 0.91 0.23 0.07. How this iron core is formed and how such a high density is reached is still not clear, and we discuss the possible pathways of formation of such a small ultra-dense planet.